The Decision Chair You Never Asked to Sit In

You've been making decisions your whole life – at work, with finances, about major purchases. But this feels different, doesn't it? When your wife used to handle the doctor's appointments and you managed the investments, there was balance. Now you're sitting across from a neurologist, trying to absorb information about medication changes while also remembering to ask about the physical therapy schedule she mentioned last week.

The role reversal hits you at unexpected moments. Maybe it's when you're standing in the grocery store, realizing you don't know which yogurt brand she's always bought. Or when her sister calls asking about holiday plans, and you're the one who needs to make the call about whether traveling is still manageable.

The Weight of "Final Say"

Here's something nobody tells you: becoming the primary decision maker doesn't happen overnight, and it doesn't come with a manual. One day you're partners making choices together, and gradually – sometimes suddenly – more and more decisions land on your shoulders.

This isn't about control or authority. It's about responsibility, and the weight of knowing that your choices directly impact someone you love who may not be able to advocate for themselves anymore. That's a heavy load to carry, and it's okay to admit it feels overwhelming sometimes.

You might find yourself second-guessing decisions you would have made confidently in other areas of life. The stakes feel different when it's about her dignity, comfort, and safety. When it's about preserving whatever independence she still has while keeping her protected.

Making Peace with Imperfect Choices

The hardest part? There often isn't a "right" answer. Should you hire help now or wait until it becomes absolutely necessary? Is it time to take the car keys, or can you manage the risk a little longer? These decisions exist in gray areas, and you're making them with incomplete information about how the disease will progress.

But here's what I've learned from talking with hundreds of guys in your situation: you don't have to make perfect decisions. You just have to make informed ones, with love and her best interests at heart. And you can adjust course as you learn more.

Start with the decisions that have clear safety implications – medication management, driving safety, home modifications. These are often easier because the criteria are more concrete. Then work your way toward the more nuanced choices about daily routines, social activities, and future planning.

Building Your Decision-Making Support Network

You wouldn't make major business decisions without consulting experts and trusted advisors. The same principle applies here. Your support network might include:

Her primary care doctor – who can help you understand how different choices might affect her overall health and quality of life.

Other family members – who can offer perspectives you might not have considered, especially if they have insights into her previously expressed preferences.

Other caregivers – guys who've faced similar decisions can give you practical insights about what worked and what they'd do differently.

Professional counselors or social workers – who can help you process the emotional weight of these decisions and develop frameworks for making them.

Remember: asking for input doesn't mean you're not capable of deciding. It means you're smart enough to gather information before making important choices.

When She Can Still Be Part of the Process

Even as her condition progresses, look for opportunities to include her in decisions when possible. This might mean simplifying choices rather than making them for her. Instead of "What do you want for dinner?" try "Would you prefer chicken or pasta tonight?"

These moments of choice – even small ones – can help preserve her sense of agency and dignity. And they can ease some of the burden you feel about making every decision alone.

Pay attention to her non-verbal communication too. Her comfort level, energy, and overall demeanor can guide your decisions even when her words become less reliable.

The Loneliness Factor

Making decisions alone is lonely, especially when you're used to having a partner to talk things through with. You might find yourself having conversations with her that feel one-sided, or lying awake at night wondering if you made the right call about something.

This loneliness is real, and it's part of the grief process. You're mourning the loss of your decision-making partner even while she's still with you. That's a normal response to an abnormal situation.

Conclusion

Taking on the role of primary decision maker wasn't something you planned for when you got married. It's not a position you campaigned for or trained for. But here you are, and you're handling it with more grace than you probably give yourself credit for.

Every choice you make with her best interests at heart is an act of love. Every time you gather information, consult others, and take the time to consider options carefully, you're honoring the partnership you built together. The decisions may look different now, but the care behind them remains the same.

You're not just making decisions for her – you're preserving her dignity, protecting her safety, and extending the quality time you have together. That's not a burden you're carrying alone; it's a responsibility you're sharing with everyone who cares about both of you.

Your Plan of Action

1. Make a list of the major decisions you're currently facing. Separate them into "immediate" (safety-related), "soon" (next 3-6 months), and "future planning" categories.

2. Identify your advisors for each category. Write down specific people you can consult for different types of decisions – medical, financial, practical, emotional.

3. Document her preferences while you still can. Have conversations about her values and wishes, even if they're difficult. Write down what matters most to her.

4. Create simple decision frameworks. For recurring choices, establish guidelines that make daily decisions easier (like preferred restaurants, activities she enjoys, routine preferences).

5. Schedule regular check-ins with your key advisors. Don't wait until you're in crisis mode to reach out for guidance.

Sometimes the best decision you can make is deciding you don't have to do this alone.

Subscribe to The Male Caregiver’s Compass . It’s FREE! You’ll get a weekly article direct to your inbox for ongoing support.

Check out my other newsletter for anyone caring for a loved one with dementia!